Reboiler Mist Eliminators in Ethylene, C3 Splitter Heat Pumps and Refrigeration Chillers
11/15/2026Demister Sizing: Why Western and Chinese Conventions Give Different Diameters
11/15/2026Two bidders size the same demister for the same duty and come back with diameters that differ by 30 per cent. Neither is necessarily wrong. The difference usually comes from five conventions that are rarely written down in the datasheet, and each one moves the answer by a few per cent to a few tens of per cent. When they compound, the client sees a spread that looks like a competence problem but is actually a basis-of-calculation problem.
This page lists the five conventions, shows what each does to the diameter, and sets out the four lines that make two quotes comparable.
Convention 1: units, and the error that is not a few per cent
Capacity factors are published in both ft/s and m/s, and the two differ by a factor of 3.28. A mesh value of about 0.35 ft/s is the same physical velocity as 0.107 m/s. When a value is copied from one unit system into the other without conversion, the result is not a slightly small vessel, it is a vessel roughly half the diameter and a pad operating at three times its allowable velocity.
The practical rule: the number in the datasheet should always be a velocity, with its unit attached, and with the density pair it was derived from. A bare “K = 0.35” is not a specification.
Convention 2: which area is the reference
Three different areas can be meant by “cross-section”:
- The vessel or column cross-section, used when the element fills the whole section.
- The element face area, which is smaller than the vessel by the peripheral gap, the support ring and any segment left open for access.
- The net open area of the element, which is smaller again by the blockage of the crimps or the vanes.
A quote that applies its capacity factor to the vessel cross-section while the element only covers 90 per cent of it is implicitly designing for a velocity ten per cent higher than stated. That is a 5 per cent diameter effect per 10 per cent area, which is survivable; applying it to the net area as well is not.
Convention 3: the margin, inside or outside the factor
Almost every design uses a velocity below the calculated maximum, commonly between 60 and 75 per cent, to leave room for turndown, upsets and fouling. The question is whether that derating is already baked into the quoted factor. If one supplier quotes the maximum allowable velocity as its design velocity and another quotes the derated value as its design velocity, the same duty produces diameters in the ratio of the square root of the derating: about 1.2 for a 70 per cent factor.
Both are defensible. Only one is comparable. The datasheet must say which, and the safest wording is to require the design velocity at the element face, with the margin already applied.
Convention 4: density at which condition
The Souders-Brown term depends on the vapour density, and the vapour density must be the one at operating temperature and pressure. Using a density at normal conditions instead of operating conditions is a hundred-fold error for a gas that is compressed, and it is the single most common arithmetic mistake in demister sizing. In vacuum service the error runs the other way and is just as large.
Two further subtleties: the density of a mixture should be computed from the mixture, not from the dominant component; and where the vapour is superheated or contains a condensable fraction, the density at the element may differ from the density in the nozzle.
Convention 5: severity allowances
Where service is difficult, the factor is reduced, and the size of the reduction is a matter of house practice rather than a single published number:
| Condition | What it does to the allowable velocity | Typical direction |
|---|---|---|
| High liquid loading or a foaming liquid | reduces it, because the drainage capacity is the limit | derate by 20 to 30% |
| Vacuum or low pressure with high volumetric flow | reduces it, because the same mass carries a much larger volume | derate by 10 to 25% |
| Fouling or solids present | reduces it, because blockage raises the pressure drop and encourages re-entrainment | derate by 10 to 20%, and consider vane instead |
| Critical downstream consequence | reduces it, because the cost of carryover exceeds the cost of steel | derate and add a second stage |
| Clean service, generous freeboard, steady load | allows operation closer to the maximum | up to 80% of maximum |
These ranges are house practice, not clauses of a single standard, and that is precisely why two quotes differ: one house may use 25 per cent derating for a foaming service and another 40 per cent.
What the five conventions add up to
Take a clean illustrative case: 1 m3/s of vapour, liquid density 1,000 kg/m3, vapour density 1.2 kg/m3, wire mesh at a capacity factor of 0.107 m/s.
| Basis | Design velocity | Area | Diameter |
|---|---|---|---|
| K as design velocity, nominal area, operating density | 3.09 m/s | 0.32 m2 | 0.64 m |
| 70% margin applied outside the factor | 2.16 m/s | 0.46 m2 | 0.77 m |
| Plus 10% loss to peripheral gap and support ring | 2.16 m/s | 0.51 m2 | 0.81 m |
| Plus 25% severity derate for a foaming liquid | 1.62 m/s | 0.62 m2 | 0.89 m |
| Unit mix-up, factor taken as 0.35 m/s instead of 0.107 m/s | 10.1 m/s | 0.10 m2 | 0.36 m |
The first four rows span 0.64 to 0.89 m, a 39 per cent spread, and all four are internally consistent. The last row is the error, and it produces a vessel 44 per cent of the correct diameter whose pad would flood as soon as the unit reached design load. Both look like engineering; only one is.
The four lines that make two quotes comparable
- Design velocity at the element face, in m/s, with the density pair used to derive it. Not a bare factor, not a factor in ft/s, not a factor with an unstated margin.
- The reference area, stated explicitly. Vessel section, element face, or net open area, plus the peripheral gap assumed.
- The liquid load, in m3 per m2 per hour or kg per m2 per hour. This, not the droplet cut, is what limits a vane pack in most real services.
- The severity basis: which conditions were assumed and what derating was applied for them.
With those four, two quotes can be compared in ten minutes. Without them, the comparison degenerates into arguing about a number that was never defined the same way twice.
Why this belongs in the specification, not the negotiation
If the basis is written into the datasheet, the difference between bidders becomes visible and discussable: one is offering more steel for a harder service assumption, and that is a legitimate commercial choice. If it is left out, the cheaper quote wins on a smaller vessel and the carryover appears in commissioning, where the cost is not steel but a compressor inspection and a lost month.
Where the differing coefficients come from, and what a 47 per cent difference in diameter looks like on one duty, is set out in demister sizing: why Western and Chinese conventions give different diameters.
Reference
The capacity factors and the two-area sizing method referenced here follow Knoepfler et al., LNG2023, paper 3.2.1, and the standard load-velocity form quoted on this site. The severity ranges are stated as practice, not as a standard, and must be confirmed by the element supplier against its own test data for the specific medium.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do two suppliers quote different diameters for the same duty?
What is the most dangerous mistake in demister sizing?
Which area should the capacity factor be applied to?
Should the design margin be inside the capacity factor or applied afterwards?
How should severity be handled in a specification?
The new demister passes inspection and still carries over. What is most likely?
How do I prove which basis was used on an existing vessel?
- Gas-Liquid Separation Fundamentals — terminology, separation mechanisms and internal selection
- Technical Data Sheet — material and performance reference data
- All Technical Articles — complete engineering index
If you are working on a replacement
A wire mesh pad performs only if it seals to the shell all round, so the measured inside diameter matters as much as the mesh density. See the process data needed to size and select it, what can and cannot be compressed on an urgent replacement and the scope from data review through to delivery.
More on wire mesh demisters and demister pads
- How Does a Wire Mesh Demister Work? A Complete Guide – the guide that covers this device family end to end
- Reboiler Mist Eliminators in Ethylene, C3 Splitter Heat Pumps and Refrigeration Chillers
- Why a Shorter Kettle Bundle Can Need a Larger Shell: Length, Diameter and Which Area Binds
- Entrainment Prediction in Kettle Reboilers, Why the Element Is Not Free to Size, and What CFD Is Actually For
- Entrainment Control in LNG Pre-Cooling Kettle Reboilers: K Values, Disengagement and Shell Diameter
Not sure which technology fits the duty at all? Which Mist Eliminator or Coalescer Do You Need? A Selection Map by Duty compares all four on droplet cut point, pressure drop and fouling tolerance.
